Another dot in the blogosphere?

Posts Tagged ‘ipad

 
When I read an article that claimed even Apple is acknowledging that the “iPads in education” fad is coming to an end, I came to one conclusion: The article was guilty of misdirection.

The article pointed in every direction except the important one, i.e., how schools might buy technology and head in the wrong direction.

The title of the article was clickbait. It lured with the possibility of reading about how Apple admitted wrong even though there is no mention of it.

There was mention of Apple being “disappointed” by a survey’s results and the company allowing a district to switch iPads for MacBook Airs. However, the report did not state that Apple actually acknowledged that iPads in education was a fad and that it was coming to an end.

The article is guilty of misdirection, just like the school district, its leaders, and its teachers might have been. How do I know?

Consider teacher comments and statements like these:

  • “Largely gaming devices.”
  • “Students use them as toys. Word processing is near to impossible.”
  • One teacher in Virginia thought giving her third graders an iPad would enhance their learning.
  • According to one of the teachers surveyed, tablets provided “no educational function in the classroom.”

The kids are likely to expect to use iPads in school the same way they use them outside school, e.g., to play games, to watch YouTube videos, to chat with friends. If adults are honest, that is how they use devices like iPads too.

Yet the expectations of adults or teachers is not that of kids. They are unrealistic and even ridiculous.

If they would not consider typing on an iPad screen, why should they expect their students to do so? That said, kids who get used to typing on a screen might surprise adults who think that this is an inferior process.

The language of teachers reveals evidence of fixed mindsets. For example, teachers expect the iPad to enhance learning. Why merely enhance and not actually enable learning? (The former makes the technology optional while the latter makes it essential.)

If a teacher complains that the devices have “no educational function”, what functions do they mean? Are they thinking about more efficient delivery of content, ready-made tests that are quickly and easily scored, and babysitting devices?

Are teachers expecting iPads to do what can already be done? Or are they willing to change and try something new, different, and better?

Incidents like the ones reported in the article seem to keep playing on a loop everywhere. They are reminders to leaders and teachers not to get devices without rigorous professional development that changes the mindsets and expectations of teachers. Only then might behaviours change.

Anyone who still thinks or says that the iPad is only for consumption should watch this video.


Video source

Sure, it is in the hands of a master. But why should apprentices not practice and create on the same?


Video source

I wonder…

If we invited “aunties” and “uncles” outside of NIE, would they sign up for this iPad workshop?

Note: No iPads were harmed in the making of this video.

The day the iOS 6 jailbreak was available from evad3rs, I successfully jailbroke an iPhone 4, iPad 2 (3G), and an iPad mini.

The iPad mini, which was already on version 6 of the OS, provided the best jailbreak experience. The process took just a few minutes.

The iPhone and iPad were still in version 5 and had to be wiped, updated, reinstated, and then jailbroken. But all is good now.

The only bug I have noticed is that text shortcuts (e.g., for “omw” to become “on my way”) do not work on the iPhone even though they work on the iPads.

Why do I opt to jailbreak? I explained briefly here https://ashleytan.wordpress.com/jailbreak-apps/ but I thought I should elaborate.

I take ownership of my devices and what I do with them. That means customizing them to make them do what I want them to do.

  •  I want my default browser to be Chrome and my go-to map to be Google Maps.
  •  I want to be able to tether my phone any way I want in any country I travel to because I have bought the bandwidth and the data plan.
  •  I want to be able to toggle between multiple Apple store accounts. (I have more than one account because a few apps are not available in Singapore!)
  •  If there is something irritating or lacking in iOS, I want to remove that irritation or add some functionality.

I do not jailbreak to get paid apps for free. I want my device to work conveniently, efficiently, and effectively, so I jailbreak it.

The practice of jailbreaking got me thinking about how there is similar trend in education.

I think more people will want to “jailbreak” education because schools and universities are not responding fast enough. They want to customize their experiences and they want what works for them.

Learners might accept an initially one-size solution, but they will want to tweak it or transform it to their needs. If schools and universities are not prepared to help learners do this, there are stakeholders will find jailbreak solutions.

It is possible to present with an iPad, but the device was not really made for presentations.


Video source

But here is a pair of presenters who take iPad-based presentations to a whole new level!

The novelty and effectiveness of the presentation does not really lie with the iPad. It is the story that they tell that matters.

Lecturing with a board, overhead projector, computer, or iPad is not going to make much of a difference if the nature of the lecture does not change. It is the storyteller that matters.

Recently, Edudemic featured an infographic by OnlineTeachingDegree (link removed on 24 Mar 2013 at publisher’s request) of the numbers game between e-books on iPads and traditional textbooks. I could bring up Richard Byrne’s critique of infographics, but I shall not even though it applies in this case.

It should come as no surprise that textbooks cost less than iPads. But that is if one only focuses on the financial cost of the media tools.

The graphic conveniently fails to point out that iPads are not just reading devices. The iPads cost more because they are more. They are also disruptive in ways that challenge both teaching and learning.

The graphic does not illustrate the cost of NOT using such a technology in powerful ways. It cannot and it dares not. To do so would be to encourage some critical discourse and favour change. Perish the thought!

ipads-vs-textbooks

Source (link removed on 24 Mar 2013 at publisher’s request)

If you need to see how fickle the publishers of infographics can be, you need only look at the one offered by OnlineUniversities which focuses on how e-books are giving textbooks “a run for their money”!

We were honoured to have Dr Seah-Tay Hui Yong of Nanyang Girls High School (NYGH) to present a short keynote and share at a concurrent session at e-Fiesta 2012.

NYGH is one of several schools in Singapore that have adopted the iPad as a learning tool. It is one of very few (or perhaps the only one) that has a long term pedagogical plan and vision where the iPads are concerned.

I think that the plan stems from two underlying beliefs. First, to paraphrase what Hui Yong shared: We are trying to educate 21st century learners with 20th century teachers in 19th century classrooms. Outdated strategies constrained by outdated environments do not make for progressive and relevant education.

That is why she shared the vision of what the classroom might look like.


Video source

The second belief is that teachers need to question how and why they teach. Hui Yong mentioned that she wanted to create an environment where the teacher did not know where to stand. A classroom where there is no single central focus is one way to do that.

I would take that statement a bit further. I would create conditions where the teacher would not even know what to do at first. The teacher would then have to be a learner or co-learner. The teacher would have to relearn how to teach or how NOT to teach in order that students learn.


http://edublogawards.com/files/2012/11/finalistlifetime-1lds82x.png
http://edublogawards.com/2010awards/best-elearning-corporate-education-edublog-2010/

Click to see all the nominees!

QR code


Get a mobile QR code app to figure out what this means!

My tweets

Archives

Usage policy

%d bloggers like this: